How can hope be foolish?
Coming from the phrase "a fool's hope," I really wonder what Tolkien was getting at when he wrote this phrase in his Lord of the Rings Trilogy. In The Return of the King, Gandalf is asked by Pippin if there is any hope, and he replies, "There never was much hope. Just a fool's hope." Now, this response is supposed to be endearing to Pippin, as he is commonly called a fool throughout the story; however, I think we can learn from this as well.
Here is what Dictionary.com has to say about a fool:
1. a silly or stupid person; a person who lacks judgement or sense.
2. a professional jester, formerly kept by a person of royal or noble rank for amusement: the court fool.
3. a person who has been tricked or deceived into appearing or acting silly or stupid: to make a fool of someone
4. an ardent enthusiast who cannot resist an opportunity to endulge an enthusiasm (usually preceded by a present participle): He's just a dancing fool
5. a weak-minded or idiotic person.
One night, I asked my friend if she thought hope was foolish. At first, her answer was, "yes". But the context needs to be know. Currently, she is being bombarded with the frustrations of an ex-boyfriend who won't let her go, a friend who desperately wants to be more, and the fea
r that she will never find a good guy. She is losing hope while contending with the guys' hope that she will chose them.
Put yourself in this situation. Does hope seem stupid? Tricky? A part of the joker? An addiction of the desperate? A characteristic of idiots who won't get the picture?
When we have been hurt, do we really want to hope? When we have hoped but not seen that hope realized, do we give it up as a fool's practice? When we know without a doubt that a bad situation will not change, do we still hope that it will? Aren't we supposed to always hope, never
give up? "But if we hope for what we do not see, we wait for it with patience."~Romans 8:25 "But as for me, I will watch in hope for the Lord, I wait for God my Savior; my God will hear me."~Micah 7:7
It would make my friend's life so much easier if those guys would just stop hoping that they will eventually win her over. It woul
d be much less painful to just give up and not care about our "useless" hopes than be disappointed again and again. But, we can't give up. "Hope deferred makes the heart sick..." Proverbs 13:12 Even the most cynical person you know holds on to hope. The way we can tell when a person has officially dropped hope is when they become depressed.
I've started answering another question of hope: When is hope a bad thing? I want to save this question for the next blog (yu
p, we are going into a part 4. Who would have thought half of Hebrews 11:1 could generate such a long discussion?).
But, in answer to if hope is foolish, here is what you think: no. My friend mass texted her hundreds of contacts with the question I posed her, and the VAST majority answered 'No way!'.
I think yes and no. Under the view of the "experienced, well-knowing" world and society, hope can be very foolish, especially if it goes against the facts. But, as Chirst's followers, we aren't called to look prudent in the world's terms. Sometimes, we are going to looks silly or foolish. However, we just have to remember Who's opinion of us really matters, which is really difficult at many times, I'll admit.
A story about hope: There was once a man who loved wolves. Since the wolves of the area were losing their habitat, he bought a perfect piece of land that would be more than big enough for the wolves to live in. Going into the woods, he found and befriended the weaker wolves who were at the lowest rank of the pack and soon brought them back to his land. There were many wolves who remained in the original woods because they were more cunning and powerful.
The weak pack grew strong under his watch and soon followed him as their alpha. To see the pack and him together would be like seeing over-joyed puppies with their father. Tails always wagged and a his face always smiled.
Soon, he gathered his pack and took them to the original woods. Sending them out, the new pack was to bring the left behind wolves to the man so he could take them back to his land. Some of the wolves were astounded at the changed wolves' confidence and joy, but many of the higher-ranked wolves growled and threatened the changed wolves as outsiders. Those who were tired of how the pack lived left with the changed wolves, and cautiously met the man. He took them with him, and the changed wolves adopted them happily as one of the pack. The man and his pack returned repeatedly to the woods. Sometimes more wolves would join their numbers, but other times, they would be chased out of the woods as outsiders.
One day, the man and his pack returned to the woods only to be barricaded by the alpha and his closest mates, fangs and growls making their points very clear. There were still many many wolves left in the original woods. The man's wolves barked and signed their message: that the man could take them to a better place. But the wild wolves threatened to attack. Calmly, the man asked his wolves to step aside. Knowing that the wild wolves would rip him to pieces, the changed wolves ignored him and only tightened their protective circle of him. He rested his hand on each wolf's head, reassuring them that he would be alright. Many whimpered against his wish, but the changed wolves broke their circle and backed away.
The man hoped that he could bring the wild wolves to himself by showing he wasn't a threat. Calmly kneeling down, making himself at the wolves' eye-level, he looked deeply into the alpha's eyes. He inwardly pleaded for the wolf to trust him, and extended his hand out to the wolf. The alpha bristled and leapt forward with a growl, sinking his teeth into the man's hand. A cry left the man's lips, and a tremor ran through his body, but he otherwise remained kneeling with his hand in the alpha's mouth. Growl's, yelps, and cries burst from the changed wolves' pack, but they stayed put, hoping their Alpha knew what he was doing and secretly afraid of the wild alpha and his pack.
The changed pack howled in horror as their Alpha was attacked by the wild pack and carried deep into the woods by their ferocious appetites. Some of the changed wolves ran after the man, but the wild ones on the edge of the mass attacked them. Those brave few were forced back onto their haunches with the rest of the changed ones. Their cries filled the area as the growls and barks of the wild pack faded away with their Alpha.
Night came, and some of the changed wolves suggested going back home, but many growls answered them. They would wait. So, like statues, the wolves sat at the edge of the woods they used to call home, hoping that their Alpha would return.
Have you ever felt like your Alpha has been carried away by the world? Has He abandoned you? Do you still have the hope that He will win in the end?